I recently had a vivid dream that stayed with me long after I woke up. It wasn’t dramatic in the way nightmares are, but quiet, beautiful, and unsettling. As I reflected on it, I realized it was a kind of parable; an image of temptation and sin that felt deeply personal. What struck me most wasn’t just the danger in the dream, but how persistent the desire was, even after I had experienced its cost.
This is the dream.
I lived on an island high up among soft, rolling sand dunes, surrounded by stunning, crystal-clear turquoise water. From above, the ocean looked calm and inviting, almost unreal in its beauty. My friends and I would walk along narrow trails that followed the edges of the dunes, stopping often to look out over the water. We dreamed aloud about swimming in it, imagining how refreshing and freeing it would feel.
But the reality was always there, just beneath the beauty. The edge of the dune dropped almost straight down; hundreds of feet of loose sand ending in jagged rocks where waves crashed relentlessly. It was obviously far too dangerous. Still, just beyond the rocks, we could see a sandy ocean floor and tranquil water. That vision pulled at us more strongly than the warning signs pushed us away.
One day, we decided we couldn’t resist anymore. One by one, we began trying to climb down the sandy cliff. Almost immediately, my hands and feet lost their grip. The sand gave way beneath me, and I began to slide. I couldn’t stop myself. Panic flooded in as I became certain I was about to crash into the rocks below and die.
I clawed desperately at the sand, trying to slow myself. Somehow – barely – I made it to the bottom alive, tumbling into the rocks bruised, shaken, and stunned. I knew without question that I had come frighteningly close to death. Survival hadn’t been skill or strength; it was luck.
We entered the water. It was cold—nothing like we had imagined from above. The clarity and beauty hid a sense of threat up close. I couldn’t tell what might be beneath the surface; dangerous marine life, unseen currents, or a sudden drop into deeper darkness. Even the seabed seemed to fall away into an abyss just beyond where we stood. The moment felt hollow. My friends quickly climbed back out. I tried to linger, to convince myself it was worth it, but I couldn’t. Soon I scrambled back to the rocks as well.
The climb back up was even worse. The same loose sand that had carried me down now refused to hold me as I tried to climb. I feared I might be trapped at the bottom; alive, but unable to return. Somehow, again, we made it back to the top, exhausted and shaken, unsure whether we could ever do it again; or whether we had simply been spared.
As we walked away, I stopped and looked back. The turquoise waves still crashed beautifully against the rocks below. The water was still stunning. And despite everything—the fear, the cold, the danger, the near disaster—I felt the desire again. I couldn’t seem to convince myself it wasn’t worth it. I couldn’t make my heart accept what my mind already knew.
My Discernment
In the light of faith, the meaning of the dream became painfully clear. Sin often appears beautiful from a distance. From above or from imagination, fantasy, or rationalization; it looks safe, refreshing, even necessary. The danger feels abstract. But the descent is always steeper than expected, and once we begin sliding, control disappears quickly. What promises freedom delivers fear; what looks warm proves cold; what seems shallow opens into depths we cannot see.
The dream also revealed something more humbling: even after being spared, even after grace intervenes and we escape alive, the attraction doesn’t vanish on its own. This is the reality of our wounded nature. Knowledge alone is not enough to heal desire. We may survive sin and still feel its pull, which is why the spiritual life requires vigilance, humility, and grace; not just willpower. The mercy of God is what brings us back up the cliff, and the wisdom of the Church is what teaches us not to stand so close to the edge again.
Leave a Reply